Lib Dem peers defeat Government to force Prevent review
Liberal Democrat peers have defeated the Government for a second time on its Counter-Terrorism and Border Security Bill.
Amendment 32, tabled by a cross-party group of peers including Liberal Democrat Andrew Stunell, requires the Government to carry out an independent review of its Prevent strategy and publish a report within 18 months.
The Amendment was passed on Monday evening by 214 votes to 196. Following the vote, Liberal Democrat Lords Spokesperson for Home Affairs Brian Paddick said:
“Liberal Democrats have been calling for an independent review of Prevent for years because many in the communities most affected believe Prevent unfairly singles them out.
“We have always argued that a completely independent review could reassure everyone that Prevent is effective, and properly targeted on those who could potentially be a danger to society. It is essential that everyone has confidence in Prevent and that we all work together to keep us safe.
“We’re pleased Labour have now accepted our arguments and together we have voted to insist such a review takes place.”
The Liberal Democrats have also secured further concessions from the Government on new powers to stop, detain and question people at ports and the border.
Originally, the Bill would have granted these powers in connection with acts that “threaten the economic well-being of the United Kingdom”, but in response to arguments made by Liberal Democrat peer Brian Paddick, Ministers tabled amendments to limit these powers to cases involving national security.
This follows a previous defeat for the Government on Amendment 15, which sets out exemptions to the new offence of “entering or remaining in a designated area”.